Can a Cataract Come Back After Surgery?
Patients sometimes return months or years after cataract surgery saying that their vision feels cloudy again.
A common question follows:
“Has the cataract come back?”
The short answer is no. Once the natural lens has been removed during cataract surgery, that cataract cannot regrow. But another part of the eye can become cloudy later and produce symptoms that feel surprisingly similar. This is called posterior capsule opacification, or PCO.
What happens to the lens capsule during cataract surgery?
The natural lens sits inside a thin transparent membrane called the lens capsule. During cataract surgery, the cloudy contents of the natural lens are removed, but most of the capsule is deliberately left in place. The artificial intraocular lens, or IOL, is then positioned within that capsule. The capsule therefore has an important job after surgery: it supports and stabilises the replacement lens. Initially, it is usually transparent. In some patients, however, part of that capsule becomes cloudy over time.
What is posterior capsule opacification?
Posterior capsule opacification develops when cells remaining within the lens capsule proliferate or change and cause the back portion of the capsule to become hazy. The result is a reduction in the clarity of the optical pathway behind the intraocular lens.
It is sometimes called a secondary cataract, but I think that term can be confusing.
It is not another cataract.
There is no natural lens left in the eye to become cataractous again. The problem is the capsule that remains behind the artificial lens.
What does PCO feel like?
The symptoms can resemble the original cataract.
Patients may notice:
- gradually increasing blur
- hazier vision
- increased glare
- difficulty with bright lights
- reduced contrast
- a deterioration in vision that had previously been clearer after surgery.
The change may occur in one eye before the other. It can also develop at very different times after surgery. For some people it occurs relatively early. For others it may not become significant for years.
Does everyone develop PCO?
No.
Some patients never develop visually significant posterior capsule opacification. Others develop changes in the capsule that are visible during examination but do not interfere enough with vision to require treatment. The important point is not whether there is any opacity present. It is whether that opacity is actually affecting the patient’s vision or interfering with examination of the retina. A finding on examination does not automatically need treatment.
How do we know PCO is causing the blur?
This matters because not every deterioration in vision after cataract surgery is caused by the capsule.
Blur can also result from:
- a change in glasses prescription
- dry eye or tear-film instability
- corneal disease
- macular degeneration
- diabetic retinal disease
- glaucoma
- retinal problems
- swelling involving the macula
- changes involving the intraocular lens.
The eye therefore needs to be examined rather than assuming that cloudy vision after cataract surgery must be PCO.
If the capsule is cloudy and the pattern of visual loss fits, the diagnosis is usually straightforward.
How is posterior capsule opacification treated?
When PCO is significantly affecting vision, it can often be treated using a procedure called a YAG laser posterior capsulotomy.
The YAG laser is used to create an opening in the cloudy central portion of the posterior capsule. This restores a clearer path for light through the intraocular lens towards the retina. No new artificial lens is inserted. The original IOL generally remains in place.
Is YAG capsulotomy another cataract operation?
No.
It is different from cataract surgery.
Cataract surgery involves entering the eye and removing the natural lens. YAG laser capsulotomy does not involve removing another lens or repeating the cataract operation. The laser is used to make an opening in the cloudy capsule behind the existing IOL. It is generally performed as an outpatient laser procedure when clinically indicated.
Why isn’t the capsule removed during the original cataract surgery?
Because it has an important structural role. The remaining lens capsule provides support for the intraocular lens and helps keep it in the intended position. Removing the posterior capsule routinely at the original operation would fundamentally change the surgery and introduce other considerations. The usual approach is therefore to preserve the capsule and treat PCO later if it becomes visually significant.
Does everyone with PCO need YAG laser treatment?
No.
Treatment is generally considered when the opacity is affecting visual function or preventing an adequate view of the back of the eye. If a patient is seeing well and the opacity is not causing a functional problem, there may be little reason to treat it simply because it can be seen. The decision should be based on the patient’s symptoms, examination and individual circumstances.
What are the risks of YAG laser capsulotomy?
Although YAG capsulotomy is considerably less invasive than cataract surgery, it is still a medical procedure and is not completely risk-free.
Potential complications can include:
- temporary inflammation
- a rise in eye pressure
- new or more noticeable floaters
- damage to the intraocular lens
- macular swelling
- retinal tear or retinal detachment in susceptible eyes.
The relevance of these risks varies between patients. Retinal history, degree of short-sightedness and other ocular findings may influence the discussion. This is another reason the procedure should be performed when there is a clinical reason rather than simply because some capsule opacity is present.
Will the cloudy capsule grow back again after YAG?
The central opening created by the laser is permanent. For most patients, that central portion of capsule does not become opaque again in the same way. The surrounding capsule remains, because it continues to support the intraocular lens. If vision later deteriorates again, the eye should be reassessed rather than assuming that the same problem has simply returned. There may be another cause.
What if my vision becomes suddenly blurry?
PCO usually produces a gradual change rather than a sudden dramatic loss of vision. Sudden vision loss, a new curtain or shadow, flashes, a marked increase in floaters, significant eye pain or pronounced redness should not be assumed to be posterior capsule opacification. Those symptoms require prompt clinical assessment.
The cataract itself does not return
This is the point worth remembering. Once a cataractous natural lens has been removed, that cataract cannot grow back. But the transparent capsule left behind to support the artificial lens can become cloudy later. The symptoms may feel similar, which is why patients understandably describe it as the cataract returning. The distinction is important because the treatment is different. The first step is not to assume. It is to examine the eye and work out what has actually changed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a cataract grow back after surgery?
No. The natural lens that developed the cataract has been removed. A cloudy posterior capsule can later make vision blurry again, but this is posterior capsule opacification rather than a new cataract.
How long after cataract surgery can PCO develop?
PCO can develop weeks, months or years after surgery. The timing varies considerably between patients.
What is a YAG laser capsulotomy?
A YAG laser capsulotomy creates an opening in the cloudy posterior lens capsule behind the intraocular lens. It is used when PCO is significantly affecting vision or preventing examination of the retina.
Does the artificial lens need to be replaced?
Usually not. In PCO, the problem is generally the cloudy capsule behind the IOL rather than the artificial lens itself.
Is YAG laser treatment always necessary if PCO is present?
No. Treatment depends on whether the opacity is affecting visual function or causing another clinical problem. A mild opacity that is not affecting vision may not require treatment.
Can PCO happen in both eyes?
Yes. Either eye can develop PCO after cataract surgery, but the timing and severity do not necessarily match between the two eyes.
Can vision become cloudy for reasons other than PCO after cataract surgery?
Yes. Dry eye, residual refractive error, corneal disease, macular disease, glaucoma, retinal problems and other conditions can also affect vision after cataract surgery. Examination is required to identify the cause.
About the Specialist
Dr Peter Sumich is an ophthalmologist with a clinical focus on cataract surgery, laser vision correction and refractive lens exchange.
His approach to post-operative care includes assessing the health of the whole eye rather than assuming that a change in vision after surgery is necessarily related to the intraocular lens or lens capsule.
Related Articles
Why Is My Vision Blurry After Cataract Surgery?
Why vision may fluctuate or remain hazy during the early recovery period after cataract surgery.
Questions I Wish Every Cataract Patient Would Ask
The practical questions that help clarify expected vision, lens choice, recovery and risk before surgery.
Types of Intraocular Lenses (IOLs)
A practical explanation of monofocal, toric, EDOF, multifocal and trifocal intraocular lenses.
How I Think Through a Lens Choice Before Cataract Surgery
How ocular measurements, eye health and patient priorities come together when choosing an intraocular lens.
If your vision changes after cataract surgery, an eye examination can help determine whether the cause is posterior capsule opacification or another condition.
For further information, contact Dr Peter Sumich through his website.
Disclaimer
This article provides general educational information only and does not constitute individual medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Changes in vision after cataract surgery can have a number of causes and require appropriate clinical assessment. The potential benefits, limitations and risks of YAG laser capsulotomy vary between individuals.
